BUTTER BAKERY CAFE THANKSGIVING 2024 ORDER FORM

You may use this online form to submit a request for your Thanksgiving order from our bakery. We will accept pre-orders through Saturday, November 23, 2024.    We will send you an email confirmation using the information on this form within 48 hours that will include arrangements for payment.

Note that we close at noon on Thursday, Thanksgiving Day, please make arrangements to pick up your item(s) before noon if you are coming on Thanksgiving Day!

Our pies are handmade to order, from scratch, and use local and organic ingredients wherever possible.  We feature Hope Butter, pure WI Maple Syrup, and apples, pumpkins and honey sourced from local farms. Pies are 10" and serve to 8 to 10 people. We add a $5 deposit for the pie tin, but if you return the pie tin you will receive a $5 discount to use at Butter.

Our breads are baked in small, handmade batches with local flours.  We are offering a braided cranberry-walnut bread loaf and rolls that include versions of our in-house favorites.

Pies

Caramel Pumpkin ($45)

Our pumpkin pie features local pumpkins from Fairview Farm in Altura, MN.  The pumpkins are roasted in-house, lightly sweetened with house-made caramel.  This is a classic pie, not at all sugary, filled with favorite fall spices - cinnamon, ginger, nutmeg, and clove.

Local Apple Pie ($45)

A classic apple pie made with local apples from Wescott Orchard in Elgin, MN.  It starts with an all-butter crust featuring Hope butter, of course, and finishes with a crumble topping - although we can accommodate requests for a double crust.

Maple Pecan Pie ($50)

In this classic recipe from our grandmother's days, we substitute the typical corn syrup for pure maple syrup from the Anderson family in Cumberland, WI.   The result is much less sweet than the typical pecan pie but full of flavor.

Spicy Chocolate Pie ($45)

Our chocolate pie features local honey from the crew at Bare Honey in St. Paul, MN.  It is balanced with cocoa, cinnamon, and a hint of cayenne - giving this pie a subtle and pleasant heat. If you're a fan of our spicy hot chocolate steamers - this is your pie.

Breads.

Multigrain Rolls - 6 ($7.50)

We sized our house-made multigrain bread loaves down to rolls, for a hearty but not heavy option.  Dairy free.

Honey Spice Rolls - 6 ($8.50)

This recipe has been a Community Supported Bread share fan favorite, so we're offering it for the holidays for everyone! Adapted from an Ethiopian bread (yemarina yewotet dabo), this is rich with honey, butter and spices. Contains dairy.

Cranberry Walnut Rolls - 6 rolls or 1 Braid ($8.50)

Our cranberry walnut bread is the perfect complement to a thanksgiving dinner.  Choose a spectacular braid or a bag of 6 rolls. Contains dairy, nuts.

Cheesecake

Maple Pumpkin Cheesecake ($55) - 10-12 servings

Our house-made cheesecake features local house-roasted pumpkins and pure local maple syrup for a great alternative to pies.

If you are looking for an item for the next day or for another special request - please call our bakery directly at 612-521-7401 to ask about current availability of whole items for pick up - do not use this form.